Cette section vous permet de consulter les contributions (messages, sujets et fichiers joints) d'un utilisateur. Vous ne pourrez voir que les contributions des zones auxquelles vous avez accès.
Citation1. GENERAL PHILOSOPHY
Judges at tournaments are to be neutral arbiters and enforcers of policy and rules. Judges should not intervene in
games unless a rules violation occurs, they believe a rules violation may have occurred, a player has a concern or
question, or to prevent a situation from escalating. Judges do not stop play errors from occurring, but deal with rules
issues, penalize those who violate rules or policy, and promote fair play and sporting conduct by example and
diplomacy.
All players are treated equally according to the guidelines of an event's Rules Enforcement Level (REL). Knowledge
of a player's history does not influence the recognition of an infraction or the application of penalties, though it may
affect the manner of an investigation. The REL of an event defines what is expected from a player regarding their
rules and policy knowledge and technical play skill.
Treating a player differently because they once played in a Professional event would mean holding each player to a
different standard and would produce inconsistent rulings that depended on the judge's familiarity with the player.
Professionals should be able to play in Regular REL events without being held to a higher technical level of play
against less-experienced opponents who may not be as familiar with the rules.
The purpose of a penalty is to educate the player not to make similar mistakes in the future. This is done through
both an explanation of where the rules or policies were violated and a penalty to reinforce the education. Penalties
are also for the deterrence and education of every other player in the event. A penalty should not be deviated from
for the purpose of education or because a player did not realize that what they were doing was incorrect. Infractions
are also used to track player behavior over time.
CitationAPPENDIX A — PENALTY QUICK REFERENCE
Infraction Regular Competitive Professional
Deck/Warband Error (DWE)
DWE — Illegal Decklist Game
DWE — Illegal Deck (Legal Decklist) Game
DWE — Illegal Deck (No Decklists) Game N/A
DWE — Improper Registration of Limited Card Pool Caution Warning
DWE — Failure to Desideboard Game*
DWE — Lost Miniature Caution
Game Play Error (GPE)
GPE — Incorrect Representation Caution
GPE— Illegal Game State Warning
GPE — Missed Trigger Warning
GPE — Failure to Reveal Warning Game
GPE — Game Rule Violation Warning
GPE — Failure to Maintain Game State Warning
Tournament Error (TE)
TE — Tardiness Warning Game*
TE — Playing the Wrong Opponent Warning
TE — Slow Play Warning
TE — Insufficient Randomization Warning Game
TE — Failure to Follow Official Announcements Warning
TE — Player Communication Violation Warning
TE — Draft Procedure Violation Caution Warning
Unsporting Conduct (USC)
USC — Minor Warning
USC — Major Game*
USC — Randomly Determining a Winner Disqualification without Prize
USC — Bribery Disqualification without Prize
USC — Aggressive Behavior Disqualification without Prize
USC — Theft of Tournament Material Disqualification without Prize